
Questo articolo merita di essere letto in dettaglio perché è un classico esempio del "grande equivoco" ovvero di come le tesi dei proponenti di un imminente declino della produzione petrolifera vengano presentate in una forma distorta. Il sig. Vierbuchen, in sostanza, sta criticando una serie di affermazioni da lui inventate che non corrispondono alla posizione delle persone che lui sta criticando.
Il metodo di Hubbert nella forma che Vierbuchen critica, è obsoleto, nessuno usa più un modello così semplificato se non per un esame preliminare dei dati. Si usano oggi metodi statistici ben più sofisticati e, va notato, questi nuovi metodi danno spesso picchi di produzione che avvengono prima di quelli previsti dal semplice modello di Hubbert. (vedi per esempio Guseo oppure Bakhtiari)
Exxon mette le mani avanti dicendo che il picco ci potrebbe essere molto prima per cause "diverse dalle limitazioni delle risorse." Così dicendo Vierbuchen non si rende conto di aver dato ragione alle persone che sta criticando. Nessuno dice che il picco ci sarà soltanto per la limitazione delle risorse. Il fatto stesso che si parli di un picco e di un declino graduale, non brutale, vuol dire che ci sono dei fattori in gioco che sono diversi da quelli della pura carenza delle risorse
Questo è, appunto, il "grande equivoco". Da una parte c'è chi, come Vierbuchen, dice "Ci sono ancora risorse, dunque non c'è un problema", dall'altra chi dice "ci sono ancora risorse, ma c'è un problema". Il picco non nasce dalla pura carenza fisica delle risorse, nasce dall'interazione fra la graduale riduzione delle risorse e altri fattori, principalmente economici, ma anche politici, tecnologici, eccetera.
Insomma, tutti stanno dicendo la stessa cosa. Neanche Exxon nega che il picco ci sarà. Lo sposta soltanto di una ventina di anni nel futuro e neanche dicendo con certezza che non ci sarà prima; dicono solo che è "improbabile" che ci sia. Difficile non pensare che sia un ottimismo veramente eccessivo, ma, tutto sommato, anche ammesso che avessero ragione, cosa cambia?
Ecco l'articolo completo
________________________________________________________
Exxon Mobil's (NYSE: XOM - News) position is to disagree that the current state of affairs represents any sort of present or imminent "peaking" in world oil output. In fact, Exxon's stated position is this:
There are numerous examples of new technology, as well as novel ways of thinking, that have and will in the future contribute to reserve growth. First, the more wells that are drilled in any region, the better the geological control over that region. More wells equals more knowledge of the exact types and depths of rocks, as well as subsurface structures and rock and reservoir conditions. This greatly facilitates expanding the resource base.
Second, new advances in seismic processing have given geologists better imagery of the subsurface. It is now possible to identify features that were formerly simply unknown and unknowable with previous technology. Even with older seismic methods, these features were indecipherable on the best of days. This new look from seismic processing facilitates improved reservoir modeling and better well placement.
Once a well is completed, there are new methods to stimulate production, over and above classical pressure-maintenance techniques such as water flooding. These include new methods to fracture the reservoir rock and increase the surface area of rock face, from which oil can migrate toward the borehole. The new methods include advanced chemical mixtures that can dissolve the rock matrix, as well as enhance the oil recovery with chemicals such as "surfactants" that essentially wash the oil out of the rock pores.
In the U.S., large areas onshore, and essentially all of the offshore areas outside of the western Gulf of Mexico and parts of Alaska, are off-limits to new drilling. In the U.K., the government has just raised tax rates to an onerous level that will inhibit future exploration in the North Sea. Issues of resource nationalism in nations from Russia to Venezuela are making future investment by any but the national oil companies (NOCs) - or politically favored outsiders - problematic. War in Iraq is preventing almost any petroleum development at this time. Insurrection in Nigeria makes for tough going in that part of the world. And the list goes on.
At the end of the argument, however, Exxon Mobil is not stating that there will never be a peak in rates of oil extraction. Instead, the company is arguing that any valid predictive methodology should properly place that event 25 or more years in the future. Specifically: "It does not follow that there is unlimited potential for production growth, rather that the eventual peak in global production is likely to be much further in the future than is commonly suggested."
Exxon Mobil also notes that "it is possible that the peak, when it occurs, may result from a cause other than resource limitation (e.g., government policies, lack of access to existing resources, competition from alternative energy sources, improvements in energy efficiency)."
So Exxon Mobil is not claiming that there is no Peak Oil problem. It is just a question of timing and time frames, and according to the world's largest publicly traded oil company, the time for Peak Oil is not now or in the immediate future. To the extent that there is an oil supply problem anywhere on the near horizon, the Exxon Mobil view is that it derives from limited access to prospective regions and under-investment in exploration, development and other related extractive infrastructure. To the extent that prices are rising, it is because global demand for liquid hydrocarbon has been strong and growing, particularly in the developing world, and certainly in China and India.
Whether Mr. Vierbuchen and Exxon Mobil are correct or wildly incorrect about the timing of a peak in world oil production is something that many of us will probably live to see.oo! Answers users.
/















